Robots for the Rest of Us

Robots for the Rest of Us

Share this post

Robots for the Rest of Us
Robots for the Rest of Us
More On the Robot Pet Question

More On the Robot Pet Question

A (I hope) clarifying addendum

David Berreby's avatar
David Berreby
Jun 10, 2024
∙ Paid
1

Share this post

Robots for the Rest of Us
Robots for the Rest of Us
More On the Robot Pet Question
6
1
Share
Illegal in many jurisdictions. But not all.

It is a truth universally acknowledged that one realizes how best to write a Substack post two hours after it has been sent out into the world. Usually I shrug off this feeling, but for the sake of clarifying what’s interesting about the question of “robot pets,” I want to add a thought to my last post.

Recap: The question is, would people ever want to have robot dogs, cats, or other pets?

I think this is a knot of several questions, about which the clearest way to think would be to ponder this statement:

I really loved X, but then X became inconvenient and annoying, and really expensive too. X just doesn’t do what I want any more. So I went down to that place where they said they’d take care of it, and I dropped X off. I’m going to get a new one soon.

Option 1: X is a child.

If X is my daughter, then I am — psychologically, morally, legally — a monster. A parent’s love for a child should be stronger than irritation, frustration, cost or any o…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 David Berreby
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share